Axeman's Arrival: Fear and Musical Omen in 1918-1919

Between May 1918 and October 1919, New Orleans was gripped by intense fear. An unknown serial killer, dubbed The Axeman of New Orleans by the press, primarily attacked Italian-American citizens in their homes with a shocking brutality that sent shockwaves through the city. The perpetrator, often referred to as the Axeman, typically broke in by removing panels from doors, used the victims' own axes for the fatal attacks, and then vanished without a trace. One of the most bizarre aspects of the case was a mysterious letter that linked this wave of violence to the city's vibrant jazz scene, adding a surreal layer to an already macabre mystery and a deeply disturbing unsolved case. What began as a series of brutal murders in New Orleans history evolved into a narrative where music suddenly played a central role in the fight against an invisible enemy.

First Strikes: Maggio Murders and Axeman's Signature

The terror in New Orleans escalated on May 23, 1918, with the brutal murder of the couple Joseph and Catherine Maggio. They were found murdered in their apartment above their grocery store; Joseph with his throat slit and Catherine killed with an axe – a weapon that turned out to belong to them, taken from their own crime scene. This modus operandi – cutting a way in through a back door and using weapons found in the home – quickly became the Axeman's chilling signature. Just a month later, on June 27, Louis Besumer and Harriet Lowe were attacked under similar circumstances; Besumer survived, but Lowe later died from her injuries. The New Orleans Police, led by Inspector Frank Mooney, faced enormous pressure to solve these violent crimes. Suspicion briefly fell on Joseph Maggio's brother, Andrew, but he was later cleared, and the hunt for the true cold-blooded killer continued.

Targeted Attacks: Italian-Americans and Axeman's Motive

A clear pattern quickly emerged: about 80% of the victims were Italian-American citizens, many of them grocers. This led to widespread speculation about whether these brutal murders were motivated by ethnic hatred, as Italian immigrants constituted a significant part of New Orleans' population at this historical time. Prominent newspapers like the Times-Picayune covered the case intensively and contributed to the panic with sensationalist reports suggesting everything from Mafia feuds to acts committed by an individual possibly exhibiting psychopathy. Early criminological profiles suggested that the Axeman might primarily target women, only killing men if they got in the way – a theory supported by the attack on the pregnant Anna Schneider, where her husband was left unharmed. However, this was contradicted by later murders, such as that of barber Joseph Romano in August 1918, indicating that men were also direct targets of this ruthless violence.

Letter from Hell: Jazz Ultimatum and Gretna Attack in 1919

The case of The Axeman of New Orleans took an unexpected and chilling turn in March 1919, when the Times-Picayune newspaper received and published a letter, purportedly from the Axeman himself. This infamous letter from the Axeman, dated 'from the hottest hell,' was written in a theatrical and threatening tone. The presumed serial killer boasted of his supernatural abilities and declared he would attack again on March 19, exactly 15 minutes past midnight. However, there was a bizarre escape route: any household playing jazz music that night would be spared by the Axeman. New Orleans, known for its unique culture, reacted promptly. That night, the city's streets and homes filled with the sounds of jazz. Orchestras played on every street corner, and people gathered to play music in their living rooms. Miraculously, no one was attacked in New Orleans that night. Shockingly, Rosie Cortimiglia and Charles Cortimiglia were brutally assaulted the next day in Gretna, a suburb of New Orleans, and their young daughter Mary Cortimiglia died in what appeared to be a brutal attack on the family.

Wrongful Convictions, Final Victim: Axeman Hunt in 1919

The Cortimiglia case led to one of the darkest chapters in the investigation of The Axeman of New Orleans: a hasty trial where a traumatized Rosie Cortimiglia, under enormous pressure, mistakenly identified her neighbors, Frank Jordano and Iorlando Jordano, as the perpetrators. Despite a lack of evidence, they were convicted – the father to life imprisonment, the son to death. Fortunately, the verdict was overturned when Rosie later retracted her accusation. The New Orleans police remained stumped in their hunt for the real Axeman. The last recorded Axeman attack occurred in October 1919 with the murder of Mike Pepitone. Over the years, numerous theories about the Axeman's identity have circulated, including suspicion against Joseph Mumfre, a man with a criminal past who was killed in Los Angeles in 1922 by the widow of Mike Pepitone, one of the Axeman's presumed victims. However, like many other leads, this one went cold, and The Axeman of New Orleans was never definitively identified, cementing the case's status as a notorious unsolved mystery.

Axeman's Legacy: Unsolved Mystery in New Orleans History

The Axeman of New Orleans remains one of American crime history's most fascinating and unsolved riddles. Was the motive behind these brutal murders ethnic hatred, a morbid urge to create chaos, a perverse game with New Orleans society through the infamous call to play jazz, or something else entirely? The Axeman's use of the victims' own tools and the consistent absence of theft from the crime scenes suggest that the motive was deeper than mere material gain – perhaps a profound psychopathic urge to violate the very sense of security in the home, a trait seen in some serial killers. The case of The Axeman of New Orleans lives on in the city's folklore, in songs, and on countless ghost tours that retell the story of the jazz-loving, cold-blooded killer who transformed New Orleans' vibrant culture into a macabre spectacle and wrote himself into New Orleans history as a dark chapter. The Axeman remains an enigmatic shadow in history, a reminder of a time when fear had a face that was never revealed, but whose echo of violence can still be felt in the city's dark alleys.

Want to delve into more unsolved mysteries and historical crime cases? Follow KrimiNyt and get the darkest stories directly in your feed.